14 Comments
founding

"An atrocity of this magnitude warrants a blockade, one explicitly aimed at toppling that miserable regime."

As much as I'm inclined to this, we all know who really ends up suffering when this sort of thing is done to a dictator.

Expand full comment

"The 80s called; they want their foreign policy back." - That One Guy, That One Time

Expand full comment

Tim Smyth11 min ago

Apparently over the weekend the global airline lobbying group IATA blasted the EU decision to ban EU airlines from overflying Belarus calling a politicization of airline safety and saying that the passenger aboard the Ryanair flight were never in danger in terms of their personal safety. I am really hope Claire, Monique, and the other CG's that like to go after the EU Commission also denounce IATA and it's membership which is basically every airline in the world including all of the major US carriers. In particular Hungarian Low Cost Carrier Wizz Air(and I think it is not a coincidence that it is a Hungarian/Orbanland Airline doing this) also put out a statement blasting the EU decision saying individual airlines should be able to manage safety as part of their internal decision making process(For me personally I think Wizz Air is on my permanent no fly list)

https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/global-airline-body-blasts-eu-safety-regulator-over-belarus-ban-2021-06-04/

So again remember for all the complaining of the EU not doing enough the EU and global airline industries are complaining it is already too much.

Expand full comment

Below is the current FAA and Biden US DOT position towards US Airlines flying over Belarus. Notice the absence of terms like prohibit or ban and instead the use of assess, investigate, caution, and advise.

https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/us_restrictions/media/KICZ_A0017-21_Advisory_NOTAM-Belarus_Minsk_FIR_(UMMV).pdf

Expand full comment

The question at hand is a simple one: Is the West—if that remains a valid term—willing to do anything about this outrage beyond the symbolic and the rhetorical? Now in my opinion that’s a question asked and answered. But I’d be glad to learn—with evidentiary support—that I’m being unduly cynical.

Expand full comment

So on the question of whether the "West" should allow overflights of Russian Airspace most especially on routes not going to or from Russia there are some things to keep in mind.

1. While these overflights rights definitely make life more "convenient" for airlines and travelers of the west, Russia and its airlines also have certain "strategic" overflight routes such as from Russia over Europe to Cuba, Algeria, and the US and even further west over the US and Canada on the way to Cuba. So if a decision is going to made to not to overfly Siberia for safety reasons by Europe then these overflight rights by Aeroflot to go to Cuba, Algeria etc over Europe should be terminated also.

2. The US, Canada, and the East Asian democracies also have a dog in the this fight. A lot of flights from the US to Asia go over Russia too. In fact it is really only flights from California and Seattle to Japan that always stay south of Russian Airspace over the international waters of the Pacific. So readers of the CG in the US or American riders of the CG living outside the US I think some tough questions also need to be made of the USDOT and FAA under the Biden Administration. What is the US position on the safety of overflights over Russia by US Airlines to which right now we are not really hearing much from the FAA or USDOT despite the fact that the US is normally pretty quick to restrict US airlines from flying over different countries. In fact I don't think US Airlines have even been formally banned from overflying Belarus by the FAA.

Expand full comment

Cancel Nordstream-2. Yeah; that’s going to happen.

Expand full comment
Jun 4, 2021Liked by Claire Berlinski

What "thunderous response" do you suggest?

Casus belli [unfortunately, I've not yet figured out how to do basic HTML tags in the comments] generally want war as the response.

Perhaps another response would be to simply identify where Protasevich and his lady are being held, and simply go in and get them. The humiliation that would inflict on Lukashenko--and Putin--might be sufficient response.

We always can go to war tomorrow.

Eric Hines

Expand full comment