Some of you didn't receive Part II of the notes I sent yesterday on the Crisis in Ukraine. I'll just resend them. If you received this yesterday, please forgive me.
Since it was a response to a writing directly to you, and not a response to a public article or op-ed, I agree that it was more of a debate than a fisk. Fisks tend not to be 'back and forth'.
Although if it were a response to an op-ed it would have been an excellent fisk.
Fisk in the sense of to refute line by line, as opposed to in the sense of making something appear stupid.
Thanks. I didn't receive Part II yesterday. Has the writer of the letter responded?
It's here: https://claireberlinski.substack.com/p/letter-to-the-editor-a-response-b05?s=w
Thanks. I did get it today. I was wondering if the person you fisked so admirably has responded to you.
He has, and I've asked his permission to publish it. I saw this as "debate," not "fisking."
Since it was a response to a writing directly to you, and not a response to a public article or op-ed, I agree that it was more of a debate than a fisk. Fisks tend not to be 'back and forth'.
Although if it were a response to an op-ed it would have been an excellent fisk.
Fisk in the sense of to refute line by line, as opposed to in the sense of making something appear stupid.